akadot News Articles Columns Reviews Fun Features Forums Retail
Black Jack: The Movie
by Jonathan Decker  
blackjack-03.jpg
blackjack-04.jpg
blackjack-05.jpg
review ratings information
ratings
Overall: 6.0
The Tezuka team's masterful animation, engaging characters and intriguing premise hold great promise, but become bogged down with short cut execution and confusing medical explanations as the film progresses.

Story: 5.0
A cynical tale about performance enhancing drugs in the Olympic games, the story touches on the villainy of the pharmaceutical industry and the integrity of medical science. But the script's gaping plot holes and predictable twists do little to convey the gravity of the theme or the stakes for Black Jack himself.

Character Development: 5.0
Created in Tezuka Osamu's popular comic book series, Doctor Black Jack and Pinoko need no introduction. However, for the uninitiated, "Black Jack: The Movie" leaves a lot to inference. Doctor Black Jack is cursorily described as a nonconformist surgeon, unlicensed only because he wishes to be so. Pinoko appears to be an energetic little girl with super-strength (for comic purposes only). Though their relationship takes shape like father/daughter, their history remains a mystery.

Art/Animation: 7.0
From the opening scene in which Nicholas Doris, dripping with sweat, breathes heavily as he prepares to pole vault into history, the "Black Jack" art team executes detailed and fluid animation. However, the overuse of still frames and therma-vision shots detracts from rather than enhances the action.

Translation: 5.0
This is where the medical integrity of the film falls apart; Moira Syndrome is called both a "fungus" and a "virus," which is not possible.

Acting: 7.0
Distinctive, expressive voices wax wooden occasionally.

MPAA Equivalent: PG-13
Medical gore and violent deaths.


X-Factors

Cheesy Factor: 10
Still frames appear ubiquitously along with split-screens, rampant thermo vision and a handful of other cheesy techniques that work better in comic books.

Faith in Medicine Factor: 1.0
Considering that everything else in the movie appears so naturalistic, the fact that highly trained medical professionals trust this freakish, unlicensed gothic enigma who couldn't even sew up his own face well boggles the mind.



Love it? Hate it? Buy it.
previous pagenext page